TaroBaapG35

Well-Known Member
First Name
Jay
Joined
Sep 22, 2020
Threads
2
Messages
533
Reaction score
1,312
Location
Charlotte, NC
Car(s)
18' Audi S4, '22 M3 LR
Occupation
Finance Professional
Surprise surprise..Z finally won against the Supra in a publication.


https://www.roadandtrack.com/reviews/a40978570/2023-nissan-z-vs-2022-toyota-supra/


2023 Nissan Z Performance vs. 2022 Toyota Supra 3.0

An old rivalry, reignited. The winner was clear.

BY CHRIS PERKINS

AUG 25, 2022



DW BURNETT

Nostalgia is a powerful thing. It pervades so much of the zeitgeist, with TV reboots getting cranked out at an almost alarming

rate, and vinyl record sales topping $1 billion for the first time since 1986. Car enthusiasts are a particularly nostalgic bunch; just look at the values of the cars Gen X and Millennials saw as icons. This cultural force has seen a number of great nameplates revived, like the Toyota Supra, or reinvigorated with an eye towards past glories, as is the case with the new Nissan Z.

Z vs. Supra is by no means a perennial battle like Mustang vs. Camaro, though the 300ZX and Supra went after the sort looking for a fast, technologically advanced, sports-GT through the Eighties and Nineties. Today, these two fit the more traditional sports car mold: Six-cylinder engines under a long hood, two seats in the middle, driven wheels at the back.

R&T - SvsZ_1.png


Price Comparison

This comparison test was obvious beyond any nostalgic connections. The Nissan Z costs $51,015 in "Performance" guise, makes 400 hp and 350 lb-ft from a twin-turbo V-6 and weighs 3507 pounds. The Supra 3.0 starts at $52,500, makes 382 hp and 368 lb-ft from a single-turbo straight-six, and weighs 3347 pounds.


(We're simplifying things a bit, as the base Z costs $41,015, though it does without the limited-slip differential, upgraded brakes, and sportier suspension tune of the Performance model. The Supra starts at $43,450, however, that's with four-cylinder power. Our Z tester was a $54,015 2023 "Proto" spec, mechanically identical to the Performance but with gold wheels and yellow interior accents. The Supra was a 2022 Premium model retailing for $57,355.)


Choice of venue was obvious, too. Lime Rock Park is one of America's great road courses, fast, flowing, and surrounded by gorgeous country roads that would give us the opportunity to thoroughly test each car. Lime Rock is also one of the tracks where the original Datsun Z made its mark, earning a reputation as one of the finest sports cars on sale in America. Driving a car that evokes the 240Z, channeling legends like Bob Sharp, Sam Posey, Paul Newman, and many others, was irresistible.
R&T - SvsZ_2.png


Did someone say something about nostalgia?

R&T - SvsZ_3.png



Nissan Z on Track


The Z exudes traditional sports-car charm. This new model rides on the same chassis as the 370Z, itself an update of the 350Z that entered production 20 years ago,

Consequently, it feels old, but in a good way.

While not an out-and-out track car, the Z was a joy around Lime Rock, and impressively quick. Editor-at-Large Travis Okulski was on hand to set lap times, and we followed our usual procedure where each car got a handful of hot laps. The idea is not to get the quickest time possible, but to show how approachable a car is. The Z posted a 1:02.603 in its third flying lap around the "classic" 1.5-mile layout of the circuit. A very respectable time, and one that wasn't difficult to achieve, thanks to its balanced chassis, stability under braking, and communicative controls. Okulski said the Z drives like a big Miata and everyone else agreed.

There's a fair bit of body roll in cornering, though the car never feels like it's overworking the tires. That roll, combined with well-weighted steering—and a great steering wheel—give the driver a tangible sense of connection. Okulski noted some mid-corner understeer in Lime Rock's long first turn, Big Bend, yet it can be managed with a slight lift of the throttle. It's all wonderfully cohesive, the rear faithfully following the front, giving the driver a ton of confidence.

Nissan equipped our tester with NISMO brake pads, which will be available at dealers for $450 a set. The brakes were a highlight, giving fade-free performance throughout our track time. Pedal feel was good, too, with a little bit of "sneeze factor" at the top of the travel, and easy modulation. Those are great qualities for Lime Rock, which has only one big brake zone, at the end of the front straight, where the Z was hitting around 125 mph, and a few spots where a dab of brake is necessary to scrub off speed. The only caveats here are that the pads are quite pricey and generate an extraordinary amount of dust.

The Z returns to turbocharging for the first time since the demise of the Z32 300ZX in 2000, borrowing a 3.0-liter unit from Infiniti. When you first get on throttle, there's a bit of lag, followed by the two turbochargers spooling up very progressively and providing linear delivery to a little over 6000 rpm. (Peak power is achieved at 6400 rpm, but torque drops off above 5200 rpm.) Overall, it's a very nice engine, if not entirely special, and it gives the Z serious pace.

R&T - SvsZ_4.png


Manual Is a No-Cost Option on the Toyota Supra

Our tester was equipped with a manual, and we couldn't be more delighted. Well, we could. The gates aren't as precisely defined as we'd like, and both Okulski and I worried about accidental 5-2 downshifts braking into turn one. I found the pedals to

be well-spaced for heel-and-toe, though Okulski—who has excessively long legs—didn't. It's somewhat of a moot point, because the transmission comes with auto rev-matching—something Nissan pioneered—which works intuitively. A short-shift kit would help the feel here. We kept coming back to two words: "engaging" and "fun." The Z is a great sports car, plain and simple, a reminder of why we fell in love with sports cars in the first place. For the money, a Camaro SS 1LE is perhaps a better track car, but for someone who mainly drives on the road and does one or two track days a year, the Z is just about perfect.

Toyota Supra on Track

Notably, "engaging" or "fun" were not words used to describe the Supra. Fast? Definitely. It beat the Z with a 1:02.151 and we're confident it could've gone even quicker (a Supra test we did in 2019 for an all-out lap time saw one turn a 1:01.51 at Lime Rock). Thank the Supra's Michelin Pilot Super Sports, which are superior to the Z's Bridgestone S007s, the eight-speed automatic in this test car, and a higher roll stiffness. Unfortunately, we're still about a month out from testing the new, manual Supra, making this a slightly lopsided fight.

The experience simply isn't as enjoyable. Speed comes much easier in the Supra, though there's a nagging sense that the car is more eager to bite you. The rear end is far too soft, wandering under braking, struggling with the prodigious output of the BMW straight-six, and generally unable to keep up with the very sharp front end. Unlike with the Z, where you occasionally have to think about the fronts washing out, the Supra requires focus on the rear.

It's not all bad, of course. The engine is the highlight, far smoother than the Z's V-6 and with much better throttle response despite only having one turbo. There's much more low-end torque, too, and the straight-six pulls harder to its 7000-rpm redline. Most of the time, the ZF eight-speed automatic works as seamlessly as you'd expect, though Okulski and Digital Director Aaron Brown found that it occasionally denied downshifts.

R&T - SvsZ_5.png


Interestingly, we all felt the Supra wouldn't be as engaging as the Z even if it had a manual. At least not without some meaningful chassis tweaks. The Toyota holds you at arm's length, with dead steering, and not much more feel through the seat of your pants either. It's faster in hands of all experience levels, just not fun.

R&T - SvsZ_6.png



"The Supra feels like a newer car," Okulski said. "Which is to say, it has all the bad traits of new cars and all the good traits. It's got a quicker gearbox, a much better, more responsive engine, better tires, a more connected front end, and it also feels like it was built only in pursuit of lap times, not making the driver feel involved in the process."

This Is Not the Toyota Supra I Wanted

On the Road

Out on the road, it was a similar story. The Z's playfulness stood out, and the softer setup started to make even more sense. It breathes better with the road and engages at lower speeds, even if it's easily capable of pace that could charitably be described as "extralegal." Outside the track, in the beautiful countryside at Connecticut's north westerly border with New York, the Z feels at home. At road speeds, the turbo lag and the relative imprecision of the gearbox become less noticeable. It is, however, obvious that the Z is a much older car inside, with a lot of cheap

switchgear carried over from the 370Z and other Nissan products. It's a necessary evil, as Nissan doesn't have the development budget to build a sports car from the ground up. It’s also easily forgivable because the important stuff—seats, steering wheel, transmission, pedals—is all lovely. The gauge cluster is especially great and gimmick-free, with a nice big tach in the middle and legible gauges for temperatures and pressures. Exactly what you need in a sports car. Bonus points go to the three auxiliary gauges on the dashboard, the best of which is the highly unusual turbo speed sensor, a knock-on benefit of Nissan's use of speed sensors on the turbine shafts.

The Supra's BMW roots are obvious in the cabin, and it feels much more luxurious

than the Z. There's a slickness and polish Nissan simply can't match. In some ways, the Supra is the better daily driver, the preferable car to be in when you're puttering around town, clicking off miles on the highway, sitting in traffic, listening to a podcast. Yet, when you're trying to have fun, the Supra doesn't deliver. It's a car that leaves the driver feeling cold and distant, and the suspension tuning isn't right. That rear end skips over bumps and imperfections, and it's much harder to get into a flow with the road surface beneath.

In a perfect world, you'd have the Z's chassis and stunning exterior and the Supra's engine and interior. We don't live in a perfect world, so the Z remains the best choice. After all, this is a sports car. We don't buy sports cars on interior trim; we buy them for the joy they bring to our lives.

Which brings us back neatly to nostalgia. In far more than just looks, the Z evokes the spirit of the sports car greats, its predecessors among them. It's fun for fun's sake, the rare modern car that truly engages the senses like a classic.

It's something of a triumph from Nissan. Its track record over the last few years has been lackluster. We were prepared for disappointment, but the Z lives up to its promise. It's one of the best Nissans since the GT-R. Despite being made with theoretically better, more modern components, the Supra's whole is less than the sum. I'd like to think there's a great sports car in there somewhere, and maybe the 2023 version will be exactly that. For now, if you want a great Toyota-badged sports car, buy a GR86.

For the nostalgia obsessed, the choice is obvious.

R&T - SvsZ_7.png
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
TaroBaapG35

TaroBaapG35

Well-Known Member
First Name
Jay
Joined
Sep 22, 2020
Threads
2
Messages
533
Reaction score
1,312
Location
Charlotte, NC
Car(s)
18' Audi S4, '22 M3 LR
Occupation
Finance Professional

Z06fan

Well-Known Member
First Name
Mark
Joined
Dec 23, 2021
Threads
1
Messages
66
Reaction score
106
Location
Charlotte, NC
Car(s)
Chevrolet SS Sedan, Mini Cooper S
Occupation
entrepreneur
No problems opening the link.
 

trackratZ

Well-Known Member
First Name
August
Joined
Mar 23, 2021
Threads
62
Messages
1,861
Reaction score
4,166
Location
So CA
Car(s)
240Z RB26DETT,Glady Rubi, Model Y LR, 987 Cayman S
Occupation
Software security
You had to be an R&T member to view. I canceled my membership since few months ago. R&T just didn't have much content vs other publications I prefer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DVW
OP
OP
TaroBaapG35

TaroBaapG35

Well-Known Member
First Name
Jay
Joined
Sep 22, 2020
Threads
2
Messages
533
Reaction score
1,312
Location
Charlotte, NC
Car(s)
18' Audi S4, '22 M3 LR
Occupation
Finance Professional
BUMP...Updated OP with Article.

Enjoy!
 

trackratZ

Well-Known Member
First Name
August
Joined
Mar 23, 2021
Threads
62
Messages
1,861
Reaction score
4,166
Location
So CA
Car(s)
240Z RB26DETT,Glady Rubi, Model Y LR, 987 Cayman S
Occupation
Software security
Pretty good write-up.

"A very respectable time, and one that wasn't difficult to achieve, thanks to its balanced chassis, stability under braking, and communicative controls. Okulski said the Z drives like a big Miata and everyone else agreed. "

Balanced chassis is easier to stiffen up, tune, and with better tires I bet the Z will be very competitive on a handling course. Its steering talks more, which is great. Those that have modded a 370Z should be familiar with this chassis' behavior. And I think EVERY Performance Z should come with those Nismo pads, at least should be a cheaper option for those that are interested to track, a safety feature.

The Supra reminds me of my prev E46 M3, quick to get up to speed but very touchy on corners at the limit, at the edge of snap oversteer. This was hard to tune out but easy to drift. The Z should be more neutral and predictable on high speed corners and exiting corners.

Bring out the aftermarket :)
 

Loco38SUP

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 14, 2022
Threads
5
Messages
251
Reaction score
638
Location
Seattle
Car(s)
2021 GR Supra
Occupation
Engineer
Overall good read. Its nice to see some positive insight considering all the negative publicity lately.

When they describe the Supra as not fun, they’re way off on that assessment.

“Yet, when you're trying to have fun, the Supra doesn't deliver. It's a car that leaves the driver feeling cold and distant.”

Anyone that has spent time behind the wheel of a Supra will disagree. Its nothing but ear to ear smiles every time you mash the skinny pedal.

-RJM
 

280driver

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2017
Threads
3
Messages
279
Reaction score
649
Location
Virginia
Car(s)
1975 280Z 5-speed, 2020 Toyota Sequoia TRD Pro
I like the “big Miata” comment. My parents have owned Miata’s for years and I’ve always enjoyed driving them for how well balanced they are. I’ll take a car like that plus way more power and room any day.
 
Last edited:

Kbl911

Well-Known Member
First Name
K
Joined
Mar 24, 2022
Threads
3
Messages
336
Reaction score
726
Location
FL
Car(s)
2017 370Z
Occupation
Wealth Management
Color me shocked by this. Pleasantly so, to be sure, but this has to be the first of the large publications to be so charmed by the Z as to rank it above the Supra in a head-to-head. 🤟

*Note: the photography here really highlights the color disparity between the two yellows on offer - the Supra looks almost orange by comparison, something I hadn't noticed when I see them on the streets
 

Houston.RZ34

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Threads
8
Messages
926
Reaction score
2,522
Location
Texas, USA
Car(s)
15 Q50 S (3.7) 23 Stingray HTC
Occupation
CIO
Overall good read. Its nice to see some positive insight considering all the negative publicity lately.

When they describe the Supra as not fun, they’re way off on that assessment.

“Yet, when you're trying to have fun, the Supra doesn't deliver. It's a car that leaves the driver feeling cold and distant.”

Anyone that has spent time behind the wheel of a Supra will disagree. Its nothing but ear to ear smiles every time you mash the skinny pedal.

-RJM
I must agree. The sound alone coming from the Supra gets your blood pumping (in Sport+ of course)

Both the Mk V and the Z4 sound like they wake up and choose violence, every morning.
 

Kbl911

Well-Known Member
First Name
K
Joined
Mar 24, 2022
Threads
3
Messages
336
Reaction score
726
Location
FL
Car(s)
2017 370Z
Occupation
Wealth Management
I must agree. The sound alone coming from the Supra gets your blood pumping (in Sport+ of course)

Both the Mk V and the Z4 sound like they wake up and choose violence, every morning.
Yeah, just listening to them out on the streets, there's an almost comical level of aggressiveness in the Supra's sound. The critic in question must be talking about something else or just isn't impressed by that element (or the wild acceleration offered).
 

takemorepills

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2021
Threads
15
Messages
2,393
Reaction score
5,167
Location
Seattle area
Car(s)
Q60
Overall good read. Its nice to see some positive insight considering all the negative publicity lately.

When they describe the Supra as not fun, they’re way off on that assessment.

“Yet, when you're trying to have fun, the Supra doesn't deliver. It's a car that leaves the driver feeling cold and distant.”

Anyone that has spent time behind the wheel of a Supra will disagree. Its nothing but ear to ear smiles every time you mash the skinny pedal.

-RJM
It's a different perspective. You are specifically talking about the "skinny pedal" which the critic did mention several times that the BMW is way more powerful, he described the torque advantage, lack of turbo lag, smoother inline six and pulls harder to redline.

The perspective that the critic brings is likely very similar to most of us Z fans who aren't constantly saying how much better a Mustang/Camaro/BMW/C8 on this forum.

Y'all focus on certain metrics to bitch about the Z, but a lot of us are looking at different things. I, for one, prefer the Z's interior, greenhouse and the fact that it's made in Japan. So, I totally agree with the article.
 

rocksandblues

Well-Known Member
First Name
bob
Joined
May 12, 2022
Threads
5
Messages
350
Reaction score
809
Location
VA
Car(s)
GL450, m3, e90, GLC300, Zupra, C280
Occupation
taco bell
It's a different perspective. You are specifically talking about the "skinny pedal" which the critic did mention several times that the BMW is way more powerful, he described the torque advantage, lack of turbo lag, smoother inline six and pulls harder to redline.

The perspective that the critic brings is likely very similar to most of us Z fans who aren't constantly saying how much better a Mustang/Camaro/BMW/C8 on this forum.

Y'all focus on certain metrics to bitch about the Z, but a lot of us are looking at different things. I, for one, prefer the Z's interior, greenhouse and the fact that it's made in Japan. So, I totally agree with the article.

And that is why being a car nut is so much fun!

I can appreciate and ooh and ah over JDM stuff that I have never owned and still like my quirky German stuff and we can check out each other rides at car meets, between stop lights, and most importantly on the track :)

Magazines are notoriously in the $pocket- but equally for Ford, Nissan, or BMW. At best ANY review is subjective after the 6 OBJECTIVE measurements.

99% of youtube-social media reviews are more worried about clickbait and views vs actually saying anything worthwhile.

AND we all like different things and grew up with different brands

Still offering a free track day at my home track in VA for the first Z from here that wants to come out!
 
 





Top