General Ask a Nissan Salesman Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

West Aussie

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2021
Threads
8
Messages
3,612
Reaction score
5,773
Location
Australia
Car(s)
Hyundai I20
taking bets we never see this guy again lol
That wasn’t my intention…I was asking a genuine question as someone from another country who is just plain shocked that this could be justified…so I tried to open a discussion to understand more
someone who truly wants to help would take the time to have an open debate on the subject
 

Houston.RZ34

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Threads
8
Messages
955
Reaction score
2,571
Location
Texas, USA
Car(s)
15 Q50 S (3.7) 23 Stingray HTC
Occupation
CIO
But your missing the point….if ALL dealers didn’t mark up then it wouldn’t be accepted, and therefor even privately people would not pay outrageous prices, because they could order and wait for a car to come in 25k cheaper.

A Nissan dealer in Aus told me that the Z is the first car they have even asked for a deposit for, because in the past onselling just didn’t happen. The deposit is geared to stop people taking a risk and purchasing a car for the purpose of on selling.
it’s just not a part of our car market, because it hasn’t been allowed to be
You think it's bad at the dealerships here, wait till they hit the used market lol

Place your bets, I'm thinking 60-80k "used" for the first 6-12 mos
 

DevonK

Well-Known Member
First Name
Take a guess
Joined
Mar 27, 2021
Threads
18
Messages
1,027
Reaction score
1,718
Location
Toronto
Car(s)
TBD
You think it's bad at the dealerships here, wait till they hit the used market lol

Place your bets, I'm thinking 60-80k "used" for the first 6-12 mos
That does take a lot of the risk out of buying it blind, with no test drive or even reviews available though.
 
OP
OP
McLovin157

McLovin157

Well-Known Member
First Name
shawn
Joined
Jan 27, 2022
Threads
2
Messages
273
Reaction score
346
Location
Oklahoma City
Car(s)
350Z Nismo
Occupation
Nissan Salesrep
Hey Shawn Welcome…sorry to throw you a curly straight up but….

I’ve seen you in Facebook, you had me convinced you were a nice guy until you said that you will be charging over sticker price and that dealers have no choice but to do so.

No other country feels the need to charge exorbitant rates, car shortages are a world wide problem, not just to the US …so I see no real reason to be doing this except greed.

if you can explain why you think it’s ok for dealers to take advantage of peoples desperation…please go ahead, I will probably still disagree, but I think it’s worth an open debate with those in the industry
Please don't feel bad for asking the hard questions, I don't mind at all!

So to start this off I hope that I didn't say "dealers have no choice but to do so" because I don't feel that way. However I do understand why almost all dealers are using market adjustments WITHIN REASON! For me personally I don't own a dealership so I can't set pricing but I did work out a smaller mark up that is reasonable within the market working directly though me. I understand that some have said the dealer they are working with are selling at MSRP and more power to them. However I'm guaranteeing more than anyone can. I can't speak for other dealers but I've been working tirelessly to ensure we have more Z cars than any dealer in the US so people will get their car quicker. I'm also networking with local car groups and other orderers to introduce people to local groups or other Z owners. Along with ensuring people are getting the cars they order without shorting on any features or options that Nissan will allow.

Now "justifying" a market adjustment is simple supply and demand WITHIN REASON. For starters I have to say I by no means support the 15k markup average to a highest of 30k mark up I've heard of on these cars, that is just stealing. Now for a justifiable adjustment; before the shortage we used to sell 150-250 new cars a month. At an average of 200 cars making lets say 2k on each car thats 400,000 in profits. Now in the current market we sold 62 last month and at the same rate thats only 124,000. Which would result in a loss of 69% (nice) and that's how people get laid off real fast. So to make up the loss in income due to supply shortages a mark up on the product is required to keep pace.

Other things that aren't helping are manufactures pulling rebates, manufactures pulling incentives and bonus plans for dealers and salesman as well. Those are other avenues of income that are pretty much dried up as well so now a majority of the income made at a dealer has to be made on the car not just the entire process.

I hope that answers your questions :)
 
OP
OP
McLovin157

McLovin157

Well-Known Member
First Name
shawn
Joined
Jan 27, 2022
Threads
2
Messages
273
Reaction score
346
Location
Oklahoma City
Car(s)
350Z Nismo
Occupation
Nissan Salesrep
I'm sure it's not him, personally, but the store's management.

On the side, I was a Nissan salesperson when the Z32 came out. I was my store's expert and could give a test drive to curl your toes. It was an exciting time.

Doubly cool, we were within driving distance to Sebring and got free tickets to see Brabham and Robinson kick ass on the track.
Ridiculously jealous of you. That would be a freaking dream to give test drives like that!
 

Houston.RZ34

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Threads
8
Messages
955
Reaction score
2,571
Location
Texas, USA
Car(s)
15 Q50 S (3.7) 23 Stingray HTC
Occupation
CIO
That wasn’t my intention…I was asking a genuine question as someone from another country who is just plain shocked that this could be justified…so I tried to open a discussion to understand more
someone who truly wants to help would take the time to have an open debate on the subject
Are you trying to be mature, logical and civil?! - this is the internet for fuck's sake!
 
OP
OP
McLovin157

McLovin157

Well-Known Member
First Name
shawn
Joined
Jan 27, 2022
Threads
2
Messages
273
Reaction score
346
Location
Oklahoma City
Car(s)
350Z Nismo
Occupation
Nissan Salesrep
Yeah there's no way anything productive can happen in this thread. He's not going to leak any info with his real name on here, and if he's already admitting to charging over sticker, he's not going to get any sales from here.

The people who are going to pay $20k over for your first allocations arnt the ones spending time on the forums, pouring over every drop of info we get, participating in civil discourse. Most of us here are enthusiasts who see the car for what it is.

If you were just an enthusiast who wanted to be apart of the community, you wouldn't have sold us on your rich history with z's to try and be our friendly nissan insider, but we all know how sales people are. Good luck selling nitrogen.
It is you who are mistaken if you truly believe my agenda is simply to sell cars here. 1. that would be ignorant to think. 2. I am genuine in answering any and all questions I can. I don't work for Nissan directly so I don't have the secret insider information but I poke and pry in the avenues I can. 3. No where did I ever say anything about a $20k over MSRP mark up. I have no idea where you came up with that other than slander. 4. You are the one making assumptions about me simply because I now sell cars. I put my little bio in the thread simply to give everyone a glimpse into myself so people could take what they wanted from it.
 

West Aussie

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2021
Threads
8
Messages
3,612
Reaction score
5,773
Location
Australia
Car(s)
Hyundai I20
Please don't feel bad for asking the hard questions, I don't mind at all!

So to start this off I hope that I didn't say "dealers have no choice but to do so" because I don't feel that way. However I do understand why almost all dealers are using market adjustments WITHIN REASON! For me personally I don't own a dealership so I can't set pricing but I did work out a smaller mark up that is reasonable within the market working directly though me. I understand that some have said the dealer they are working with are selling at MSRP and more power to them. However I'm guaranteeing more than anyone can. I can't speak for other dealers but I've been working tirelessly to ensure we have more Z cars than any dealer in the US so people will get their car quicker. I'm also networking with local car groups and other orderers to introduce people to local groups or other Z owners. Along with ensuring people are getting the cars they order without shorting on any features or options that Nissan will allow.

Now "justifying" a market adjustment is simple supply and demand WITHIN REASON. For starters I have to say I by no means support the 15k markup average to a highest of 30k mark up I've heard of on these cars, that is just stealing. Now for a justifiable adjustment; before the shortage we used to sell 150-250 new cars a month. At an average of 200 cars making lets say 2k on each car thats 400,000 in profits. Now in the current market we sold 62 last month and at the same rate thats only 124,000. Which would result in a loss of 69% (nice) and that's how people get laid off real fast. So to make up the loss in income due to supply shortages a mark up on the product is required to keep pace.

Other things that aren't helping are manufactures pulling rebates, manufactures pulling incentives and bonus plans for dealers and salesman as well. Those are other avenues of income that are pretty much dried up as well so now a majority of the income made at a dealer has to be made on the car not just the entire process.

I hope that answers your questions :)
Yes…but that still doesn’t really explain it…as I said…car shortages are a world wide issue, not confined to the us and manufactures pulling rebates, incentives and bonuses I would also assume to be world wide.

so …how come every other countries dealers can afford 0 mark ups, whilst you guys are talking a minimum of 5k?
What is different in the US to anywhere else, especially given you have the largest market share and will receive ( im guessing) far more cars than any international dealership?
 

RicerX

Well-Known Member
First Name
Z
Joined
Sep 14, 2020
Threads
3
Messages
314
Reaction score
817
Location
Limbo
Car(s)
2020 Titan Pro4X
Even 5k is too much. If Nissan thought it was worth 5k more, or that as a company they could make 5k more to help them get out of debt then they would of set the price at that.

For me it’s a moot point.
I’m an Aussie, so we don’t pay it…but if dealers want to come into a forum and say “ask me a question” they need to be ready for anything, and it is/was a genuine question
If it can’t be answerEd in an open conversation, well then he is just here to sell cars and not really here for open and honest discussion that might not always go in the expected direction.

We already know what the car looks like, what’s in it…we have Dan Passe on board that pops his head in whenever there are false claims, i could be wrong but feel we really don’t need a salesman here unless they are selling cars at msrp or a marginal increase, or offering a group discount . 5k on a 40k car is over ten percent of the original cost, and that’s not a small amount on a big purchase such as a car. For many it could be the amount that tips it into the unreachable area.

NO ONE knows pricing as of yet, or when deliveries drop.
So quite honestly I question why you would come in a forum and not expect to get grilled.
Nissan isn't marking the car up. The dealer networks are. And it's not just Nissan dealer networks. It's very important we retain this distinction. Nissan isn't the bad guy here. Nissan can mandate the dealers not mark the cars up, but there are even loopholes around this as discussed in other threads. Some owners of dealerships are buying the cars at MSRP and selling them as "certified used" at markup. Nissan can't do anything about this. This is free market economics at hand in the US.

If no one spends the money on the markups, they go away. Plain and simple. Problem is people are making dumb decisions and paying them (or they have what my friends and I refer to as "fvck you money"), which is why markups remain a thing. Buyers grow a bit of discipline and be patient, the markups disappear because dealers still need to sell cars at the end of the day. No one is buying a car like a Z out of desperation - if you're desperate for transportation needs, you're shopping Corollas and Civics, not two seat sports cars. Those are wants. Also an important distinction.

Other than that - ol buddy is here to drum up sales, and I think now he smells what he stepped in ? Thanks for stopping by, chief!
 

ZDreamer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2021
Threads
2
Messages
399
Reaction score
469
Location
Texas
Car(s)
Subaru
Hey Shawn Welcome…sorry to throw you a curly straight up but….

I’ve seen you in Facebook, you had me convinced you were a nice guy until you said that you will be charging over sticker price and that dealers have no choice but to do so.

No other country feels the need to charge exorbitant rates, car shortages are a world wide problem, not just to the US …so I see no real reason to be doing this except greed.

if you can explain why you think it’s ok for dealers to take advantage of peoples desperation…please go ahead, I will probably still disagree, but I think it’s worth an open debate with those in the industry
Lol.. what a savage. You don't need to point out that everybody got an agenda.
 

JoeTX

Well-Known Member
First Name
Joe
Joined
Sep 24, 2021
Threads
0
Messages
94
Reaction score
264
Location
Dallas
Car(s)
Bike
Occupation
Broker/ Software Engineer
Now "justifying" a market adjustment is simple supply and demand WITHIN REASON. For starters I have to say I by no means support the 15k markup average to a highest of 30k mark up I've heard of on these cars, that is just stealing. Now for a justifiable adjustment; before the shortage we used to sell 150-250 new cars a month. At an average of 200 cars making lets say 2k on each car thats 400,000 in profits. Now in the current market we sold 62 last month and at the same rate thats only 124,000. Which would result in a loss of 69% (nice) and that's how people get laid off real fast. So to make up the loss in income due to supply shortages a mark up on the product is required to keep pace.
the Manufacture put the fair price on the car, you the dealership get a discount on the car as you are a wholesaler . you are still making money either way, it's not my job to pay the difference to the dealership because they used to make money.
 

West Aussie

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2021
Threads
8
Messages
3,612
Reaction score
5,773
Location
Australia
Car(s)
Hyundai I20
Nissan isn't marking the car up. The dealer networks are. And it's not just Nissan dealer networks. It's very important we retain this distinction. Nissan isn't the bad guy here. Nissan can mandate the dealers not mark the cars up, but there are even loopholes around this as discussed in other threads. Some owners of dealerships are buying the cars at MSRP and selling them as "certified used" at markup. Nissan can't do anything about this. This is free market economics at hand in the US.

If no one spends the money on the markups, they go away. Plain and simple. Problem is people are making dumb decisions and paying them (or they have what my friends and I refer to as "fvck you money"), which is why markups remain a thing. Buyers grow a bit of discipline and be patient, the markups disappear because dealers still need to sell cars at the end of the day. No one is buying a car like a Z out of desperation - if you're desperate for transportation needs, you're shopping Corollas and Civics, not two seat sports cars. Those are wants. Also an important distinction.

Other than that - ol buddy is here to drum up sales, and I think now he smells what he stepped in ? Thanks for stopping by, chief!
I completely agree…however I can’t believe that mark ups would be any good for the manufacturer reputation, I feel these types of things only give them a bad name even when it’s not their fault. This is the reason more manufacturers are looking to sell direct …to keep their image intact
 
OP
OP
McLovin157

McLovin157

Well-Known Member
First Name
shawn
Joined
Jan 27, 2022
Threads
2
Messages
273
Reaction score
346
Location
Oklahoma City
Car(s)
350Z Nismo
Occupation
Nissan Salesrep
The response is about what I expected before I even read this. ?

I am cross shopping the MKV Supra and the Z, what would you say to help me with this decision?
The Z makes 400HP in any trim and the Supra makes 386HP but you have to start at a MSRP of 55k. Now I understand people have said if you dyno the MKV it comes to 410-420HP but I'm not subscribed to that just yet. The supra is going to be 100-200lbs lighter so it will most likely be a little quicker so that is a thing to consider. Personally I like the retro modern design of the Z vs the over designed lines of the Supra, plus I HATE fake vents. The big thing right now is that you can get the Z with the 6 speed manual without the issues that existed in the 370Z with rev match.

I think the 2 biggest contentions between these two cars for most people is going to be pricing and urgency of purchase. The Z is cheaper by a substantial margin even in the Performance trim (expecting 45-49k). However the MKV you can get now and the Z may be out in June but could be delayed again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
 






Top